Shinza

100 Decks, 264 Comments, 61 Reputation

I'd love to hear what you think of the deck!

0
Posted 21 October 2014 at 18:05 as a comment on Indestructible Devotion

Permalink

For the record, Wall of Denial laughs at Brittle Effigy from under its shroud.

0
Posted 19 October 2014 at 16:10 as a comment on Relentless beating

Permalink

Vengevine is a 4 of beast. Its like a green cousin of DoR. Only trouble is casting 2 creatures to trigger it. Gravecrawler works nicely for this. It would be nice to have another creature to bring in on the cheap.
Maybe Big Game Hunter? Madness would work well, I think
Gorgon Recluse, Grave Scrabbler could work too.

0
Posted 19 October 2014 at 16:05 in reply to #512258 on Modern Dredge Gate

Permalink

No problemo!
Glad to see the Budget Muse still graces you.

0
Posted 19 October 2014 at 15:27 in reply to #512291 on Budget EDH: Masochist Marath

Permalink

Northy! I like it!
Fantastic! I love decks like this!

Kamahl, Pit Fighter
Vulshok Sorcerer (my favorite of the pingers)
Rod of Ruin

You have a fair amount of ETB effects,
would Stampeding Wildebeests/Serow help?

I also like Harrow.

This looks like fun!

Like +1

0
Posted 19 October 2014 at 15:21 as a comment on Budget EDH: Masochist Marath

Permalink

I posted this above, but wondered if its bad form to respond to a comment in the middle of the posts. So i'm reposting it here.

Have you considered Hellcarver Demon? It goes with the theme of this deck, is a monster and could let you cheat in some huge baddies. Life from the Loam would help mitigate land loss.

0
Posted 19 October 2014 at 08:11 as a comment on Modern Dredge Gate

Permalink

Have you considered Hellcarver Demon? It goes with the theme of this deck, is a monster and could let you cheat in some huge baddies. Life from the Loam would help mitigate land loss.

0
Posted 19 October 2014 at 08:08 in reply to #511806 on Modern Dredge Gate

Permalink

Here's a modified clone of your deck to illustrate what I'm talking about.
http://www.mtgvault.com/shinza/decks/hc-loaded-for-bear/

0
Posted 19 October 2014 at 07:57 as a comment on Relentless beating

Permalink

I like this one!
I tried to access your dragonstorm one, but was brutally denied "marked as private"

The mana ramp makes the pricey dragons realistic. The combo is ruthless and the potential for 6/6 dragon tokens is cool.

One of my favorite cards is Infiltrator Lens. Its so cheap and in a deck like this one, it would fit well. You know which attacker will get blocked. Might as well get 2 cards per blocker for the trouble. Would help draw into the combo.

Here's another crazy thought. Pit fight. Its an instant at 2 cmc (hybrid) and you can use your slumbering dragon for it (as a fight is neither attacking nor defending). Let your 7/7 dragon, who is still napping, whup some ass in his sleep.

Another thought would be Branching Bolt. 3 cmc instant that targets 2 creatures (1 flyer, 1 grounder) for 3 damage each. Its a 2 for 1 to help early going.

At any rate, Like +1.

0
Posted 19 October 2014 at 07:26 as a comment on Relentless beating

Permalink

Both seem pricey to me, but Living End appears markedly cheaper.
Sounds like you have a winner!
Go for it! Carpe Diem! Excelsior! Have at it!
and of course, post it :)

0
Posted 19 October 2014 at 06:55 in reply to #512013 on Modern Dredge Gate

Permalink

This is awesome! Nicely done.
You need a way to consistently bounce.
Isochron Scepter?
Also, why Ensoul Artifact? Is that to buy time to get possibility storm out?
Maybe consider Delver of Secrets or Slumbering Dragon as a time buyer.

Like +1

0
Posted 18 October 2014 at 16:36 in reply to #512069 on Bounce, Bounce, Emrakul!

Permalink

Hmm... Both essentially hinge on one card. Both can be fun.
Maybe price it out? Given your current collection, which would cost less to create?

0
Posted 18 October 2014 at 16:22 in reply to #512013 on Modern Dredge Gate

Permalink

Well, hexproof is a pain. That is the problem, right?

What happens in the games you lose?
Specifically, do you get swarmed or Bogled (by a few super-amped little slippery buggers you can't get a knife on)?

If its the latter, you might consider white instants that say, "Target player sacrifices an attacking creature"

Celestial Flare and Dispense Justice come to mind.

Dispense Justice is the better of the two, especially if you happen to have 3 artifacts out. Even if you don't, the mana requirements are easier to manage in a deck with 3 colors.

Which brings me to my next (and perhaps more "wingnut") idea.

What if your sideboard included an artifact suite? The kind where you essentially sub in a massive amount of artifacts and Dispense Justice?
It is bizarre, but on the upside, it would not change your mana base.
Elspeth's ultimate ability would work nicely in concert with that too.

Meddling Mage already might be helpful, but may not catch the Bogle in time.

How is Rest in Peace and Grafdigger's Cage working out? Any issues with Snapcaster Mage when you play those?

Hope this helps

Like +1

0
Posted 18 October 2014 at 07:34 as a comment on WUR (Jeskai) Control

Permalink

Dkrocka,
I just wanted to take this opportunity to thank you for a spirited debate.
The best ideas get generated that way. Fun.

Brownjacketftw,
I enjoy this deck concept. If nothing else, it prompted me to consider the role and limitation of timing in the application of winning.
Thank you.

AjaniBeastMode,
Social misstep of said "bogarting" acknowledged, I will risk perpetuating the gaff by saying the following:
I will look at the deck.

0
Posted 18 October 2014 at 07:02 as a comment on Fuck Damage, Get Wins

Permalink

Well, I have favorites and will play them and then set them aside for awhile. Picking them up again to play is a happy reunion, especially as new cards come out that smooth rough spots. I've also dismantled/sold decks that I then get a hankerin' for and regret it.

Both tron and twin are popular, both can be fun. For me, the lion's share of the joy is in the construction and tweaking, so I'd encourage you to try something new.

Having said that, if you have the option at all to make the new AND keep the old, one is silver and the other is gold.

0
Posted 18 October 2014 at 06:52 in reply to #512013 on Modern Dredge Gate

Permalink

Ok. I moved Nip to sideboard to add 2 land and another Mourning Thrull and Nightsky Mimic.
While this tanks my turn 1, it also means that all my creatures are 2cmc.

It also means I live in fear of Steel Hellkite, Consume the Meek, Engineered Explosive, Austere Command, and Culling Sun.

I can live with that.

1
Posted 18 October 2014 at 06:44 in reply to #511987 on Orzhov for the Consequence

Permalink

That's a great point!
18 land is definitely questionable.
I may have to revisit that.
Serra's Sanctum! Of course! Shoot. Should have been mine!

0
Posted 18 October 2014 at 06:31 in reply to #511987 on Orzhov for the Consequence

Permalink

By all means, tell me what you think!
Enjoy!

0
Posted 17 October 2014 at 18:19 as a comment on Orzhov for the Consequence

Permalink

Well, Here it is! Orzhov without haunt and extort.
Enjoy!

http://www.mtgvault.com/shinza/decks/orzhov-for-the-consequence/

0
Posted 17 October 2014 at 18:05 as a comment on Anti-Guild Challenge!

Permalink

Here it is...
http://www.mtgvault.com/shinza/decks/to-appear-dimir/

I think I will do another. Feels like I missed the spirit of the challenge, though I think the idea is cool.

0
Posted 17 October 2014 at 08:20 as a comment on Anti-Guild Challenge!

Permalink

81-100 of 260 items