richter1

And I thought I made different decks, there is nothing wrong with making a shadow ninja deck the only problem is I can't really help you that much because this is something that I don't have much experience with or to draw from as far as cards in my binder to recommend to you. It looks like it would be fun to play but not so much to play against. If the damage is unblockable, I would try to find a quicker kill in something like infect. Other than that I am at a loss, congratulations that does not happen very often, it's just something about your off the wall decks I guess.

This is interesting but I have some questions about some of the cards in here. You know the deck better than I do so I will fire away, first off is the Sigil Captain and Knight of new alara absolutely necessary? There might be more questions later in the comment, I am trying to look at the deck in parts instead of as a whole so bare with me. Next, look up two cards lifegift and rude awakening. Garruk Wildspeaker could be a decent choice. Molimo, Maro Sorcerer would be a nice additon. Scute Mob could do some serious work for you. Perhaps a bear umbra or sword of feast and famine but I don't know if you are playing with enough creatures that will stay around for more than one turn to warrant either of those options, you are the deck builder you tell me. Lotus cobra would be one for you to look into, but the cmc on most of the cards in your deck is for the most part low and most of the deck is land so I don't know if it would do you much good. I would be afraid of someone attempting to destroy all lands and since you have access to white I would recommend Avacyn, angel of hope. Never mind that last part about the angel, I got to the part in the deck where you have answers to people trying to blow up lands, I don't feel like deleting so there.

Sorry jester, I can't help you out too much with this one due to the fact that you are sticking to your guns about being all bird - ish with your deck. Oh yeah there are angels that look like birds, this deck is too spicy for the pepper, that's all I got.

Back in the day there was a 60 card deck called squirrel opposition, look up opposition. Vitalizing wind if you want to go the death by massive squirrel win. A card like collective unconscious can get you massive card advantage if that is what you want. I love seedborn muse, it has potential in any green deck and in this one it could do some serious work. Just a card as simple as overrun would be a great addition to this deck, another possible death by squirrel option. Look up levitation, now death by flying squirrels, lol I crack myself up. And if you want one more way to copy any creature look up vesuvan shapeshifter. If you want to get stupid loose try akroma's memorial.

I found blisterstick shaman, Ghitu Slinger, Keldon Marauders and Sparkmage Apprentice, check them out and let me know what you think. The deck is slowly but surely coming together.

Lifeline is decent, the only problem is if a token creature goes to the grave ( not 100% sure but it might not even go to the grave, it might just be rfg) then at the end of tun I can't get the token back. Like the ashnod's altar idea, it gives me a sac outlet and adds extra mana for some of the more expensive creatures or to do what you were saying with skull clamp. The deranged hermit and goblin marshal are both good choices for this deck, even though the hermit is a little pricey cash wise. I don't have a dragon appeasement but I am always looking for ways to stop myself from drawing in edh so that is a good choice. I was going to try to find a way to get a card called Hellion Eruption in the deck and for whatever reason I decided to leave it out but the deck functioned quite well without it.

The only thing I see is that the metalmorph is not legal in this deck due to the blue mana symbol on the card, but that is only if rakdos is your general and I think he is. Okay I just realized after posting the comment that the deck is under construction anyhow so, I don't know where I was going with that.

Need to look up a way to give all non instants in your deck flash, while you are at it look up a card called seedborn muse. Give me a little bit more time to think up more shenanigans for your deck and it will be pimp when I get finished with it.

I had never seen waves of aggression until now, most of the others you mentioned I have in my binder. I guess you could say that my deck is the lite version just because it runs a limited number of copies of extra attack phase cards. I agree the battle cry idea is boss, if I ever get tired of the deck the way it is I will have to work on getting some of that in there. Oh geez, Tajic is a beast especially in a deck like this. I am not sure how the creatures would work out in this deck, I mean Odric and the war pride ( unless you were using Odric in your deck). You must have fallen asleep at your keyboard or something cause it seems like you trailed off on the part about dolmen gate but it would be decent in my deck so I can keep the tokens the war pride makes ( again unless you are using this card in your deck). Good stuff thanks jester

This deck is going to be amazing when you get it tuned right, I am going to kinda copy 99% of your idea and drop this deck on my local playgroup and it's gonna blow up like a bomb or something. I was looking through my crap and came across 2 more cards that must find their way into this deck. Shrieking drake and elvish visionary, wait for it you also need to find a creature that deals one damage to a player when it comes into play. It's almost time for me to turn in so I will not look for it for you but I am sure it's out there. Now you have the power to ping someone to death, lol nice deck good sir. Oh yeah there be lots of edh players on this here site and they post lots of decks but it is very awesome to have a follower, I think you will be my first. You are taking on something very ambitious if you to want to build a deck of every color combination, good luck to you on that as well. I do appreciate you taking a look at my decks and if you find something that I am using in one of my decks that could help you out please feel free to use it in one of yours. Cheers

Jester check on the venser that I was suggesting because you are thinking about the planeswaker, I am talking about the legendary creature that is only blue. Good luck with your deck and click on my user name so that you can check out and possibly leave a comment on one of my decks. Oh yeah, let me know if I can help you out any more.

Crystal shard, Erratic Portal, Deadeye Navigator to go along with the great whale or not if you don't want to be "that guy" (the one who uses the infinite mana combo). It all kinda depends on how far you want to take the deck into the bottomless pool of no return, do you want to stand on the shore on the edge of oblivion or do you want to jump in? If you don't want to hold back then you could add mystic snake and counter nearly everything or draining whelk. Let's see, Venser, Shaper Savant is a good choice and you have access to red so why not add warstorm surge. Of course after I post the comment I realize all of those creatures are a bit expensive for what you are trying to do with the deck, I see that you are running aluren. I don't really want to delete the comment because there might be something here you can at least consider using.

Sure it is, and I agree with you the mana rocks are necessary for the deck due to the high cmc of the creatures. It's good that you haven't spent any cash on the deck yet, that means you can still be flexible on your choices until you have made final decisions on specific cards. I don't really know what else to say except good luck.

It makes me happy to see that my comments get looked at. Thank you for the correction gh, good old gh, I knew I could count on you to do good math. Wanna know why? Cause math is power and it's fun.

I would say to look up Shivan Wurm, since you are using lots of wcip creatures so that you can get the effects to happen over and over again. Also out of 45 creatures 9 of them are elves, so that means 20% of the creatures are elves. The reason I give you that figure is because I think the Skyshroud Poacher might not be absolutely necessary, it might go better in a themed edh elf deck. I have been wrong in the past so take that word of advise with a grain of salt, but also take it into consideration because the slot it takes up could be filled with something else that does more for you. Okay 2 more creatures then I am done and they are; Thragtusk and Craterhoof Behemoth. Just since you are using the closet that makes both of these creatures crazy good, the behemoth might actually be better in a token deck but since you are using Asceticism perhaps that will allow you to keep more of your creatures around so that you can get a few uses out of the behemoth. I know I said I would be done but I lied, you are playing with 18 noncreature spells if I was playing this deck I would try to find a way to get that number way down. With your general on the field if you could play all of those spells without being dead, he would deal you only 108 damage. I know I am going backwards with this comment right now but my advise would be to look for a way to return him to your hand or outright slay him if you are getting close to the dead zone and really need to play a spell. Wow that was a lot of information, I have never left such a detailed comment but I think it's because I think the deck is solid and I hope it works out well for ya.

If you need a creature to absorb damage I would use Cho manno revolutionary and would enchant it with something like pariah. Doing that might keep your Elocutors in play for long enough to win, but they are still open to spot removal or something like red direct damage. If you want to stop players from targeting you specifically then I would say use true believer or something similar, especially if you know you will be facing a red mage. If my comment has helped at all then check my decks out, click on my user name. There is a black /white token deck that might help this deck out and if you did feel like making a comment about one of my decks I would really like feedback on my red/white deck or the deck I have named cat breath. Thanks in advance and if I can help out anymore let me know.

Actually erie if dirtyclown has intangible virtue out then meekstone + phantom general + talrand is okay.

Just so you know a few cards in the deck are banned in EDH they are as follows; Emrakul and Gifts Ungiven. Of course I do see that this deck is tagged as fun so perhaps you are not abiding by the ban list due to this being a "casual" deck or your local playgroup doesn't mind you have those cards in the deck and if that is the case, don't pay attention to what I just said and have fun.

FYI : Panoptic Mirror is banned in EDH, unless of course your local playgroup doesn't mind that you have it in your deck. Also take a look at zur's weirding, that could be an interesting addition. zur's weirding + puzzle box = lol, some crazy mess. One more thing the Pacts and Hive mind would not necessarily mean you have a lock on a win condition, it would depend on what other decks you were playing and if they had access to the correct mana.

Yeah I just picked up a flickerform yesterday, I was thinking about bruna when I asked my playgroup "friend" if he would trade it to me. I agree false demise is very nice.