richter1

42 Decks, 420 Comments, 69 Reputation

Yeah I feel you on taking a card out, if I were to take a card out it would be the primordial first just because the soul o t harvest is better for the amount of mana you are spending. If I did take the primordial out I would definitely put the wanderer in. Sawtooth loon now that there is a good card but sad face wrong colors.

0
Posted 19 July 2013 at 02:13 in reply to #378915 on animar

Permalink

That is funny, treefolk walking a spider.

0
Posted 19 July 2013 at 02:07 in reply to #380108 on Spider Snacks

Permalink

My playgroup "friend" made a new r/g token deck that has potential, the reason I even mention that is because he played a card that could go in this deck. Check out champion of lambholt, it could work. Also all this when a creature comes into play draw a card on a stick is kinda slow. It could come out earlier that is true and it would be a big body to block/attack and I could keep drawing cards after it's out there due to small creatures coming into play over and over but I feel like I need more. That is why I am considering something like collective unconscious and even that might not net that many cards.

0
Posted 18 July 2013 at 03:34 in reply to #378915 on animar

Permalink

Devour Flesh is also a nice card, could also consider momentous fall or greater good but the latter is one I can't afford right now.

0
Posted 18 July 2013 at 01:42 in reply to #379536 on Spider Snacks

Permalink

I really like the use of signal the clans, I would pick it over the gamble. And it might have to find a way into my deck.

0
Posted 17 July 2013 at 23:51 in reply to #379180 on In & Out the Doggy Door

Permalink

Oooohh ... Me likey Alpha Kavu. Just to be dumb you could add a Conspiracy, naming kavu. Patriarch's Bidding would be another to consider, also perhaps semblance anvil IDK of the spiders that I have seen/know about some are a good value mana cost wise and some are fairly expensive. I kinda like this idea and would have put more treefolk in my doran deck but as you know I was trying to go the treefolk theme route. That's all I can think of right now but if I come up with more fun stuff I will let you know, need to come back to this deck later and write a few cards down anyhow.

0
Posted 17 July 2013 at 23:26 as a comment on Spider Snacks

Permalink

Can't wait to see new deck (s). I like the idea of adding 0 mana cost arty creatures, I was considering doing that because I did not have the 0 mana cost red creatures you had in the deck before you changed it most recently ( you still might have those creatures in there I have not checked yet). I think they are cast even thought their mana cost is 0, I need to look that up. Yeah command tower I need to check to see if it's in my deck as well. Yeah on the mana rocks as well that seems like it could be a good idea, even thought I do run like 40 lands in my deck. I was going to add a wall of blossoms, the rest of the cards on the list there that I did not comment on I am not sure about what they do so I will look them up and I might get back to you on what I think about them.

0
Posted 17 July 2013 at 21:59 in reply to #379180 on In & Out the Doggy Door

Permalink

I am thinking about 86 ing the opposition myself and possibly adding rhystic study ... more draw power is good. Also I kinda want to add maelstrom wanderer, three mana for a 7/5 double cascade and creatures I control have haste ( that last part I don't really care about so much but I am just sayin). I also don't really care so much about double cascade in this deck it will prolly hit something small 2 times but at least it would potentially add counters to animar and something else random off of whatever creature comes into play.

1
Posted 17 July 2013 at 21:50 in reply to #378915 on animar

Permalink

Please do leave a comment but remember to look at JESTERSMIND 's "Doggie Door" deck as well and maybe even leave a comment while you are there.

1
Posted 17 July 2013 at 00:49 as a comment on animar

Permalink

really

0
Posted 16 July 2013 at 04:03 in reply to #378428 on stonebrow

Permalink

what about render silent, it seems like it would be down your alley. Voidwielder seems kinda expensive for what it does, there might be something cheaper that does something similar unless you are just trying to have a almost standard legal edh deck. really the unwinding just for the isochron, it makes sense it's just i don't even know what to say. just do the damn thing. is there enough bouncy and blinky in this deck, it's almost outta control. oh yeah and nice looking mana curve. that's all i got, going to bed.

1
Posted 12 July 2013 at 04:21 in reply to #376338 on Azorius EDH

Permalink

Don't has a savageborn, but I am looking for one.

0
Posted 11 July 2013 at 15:20 in reply to #376573 on stonebrow

Permalink

In my defense I already have a deck that has a theme of multiple attack steps. This deck is more about senior stompy with guest appearances by trample and haste, there is a smaller theme of me taking other players creatures and beating them about the arms and legs with them. The memorial would be good in here, even if to make my XXL trample, hasted creatures, XXL trample, hasted, flying creatures. The mentor is essentially a rage on a stick but I don't have it and most of the creatures in here already have trample. And it's okay with me if you want to borrow this deck or parts of it to make your own kick ass g / r deck. I have started pulling some cards to make my own version of your deck that you and I worked on. Thanks for saying it's a good deck and thanks for the advise.

0
Posted 11 July 2013 at 15:18 in reply to #376491 on stonebrow

Permalink

The deck almost has too many potential themes to work off of. Discard, elves and token creatures. And of course I want to make all of those themes work but it's difficult to do with limited card space. I also like both doubling season and parallel lives. Although I may like bottomless pit in this deck as well, I rather force opponents to drop cards and leave the ones in my hand alone. Painful quandary would go great in here, I agree I should make nath do work. Someone that was in my playgroup a long time ago was banned from using elves due to his use of devoted druid, quillspike and rite of consumption all in together in the same edh deck. To this day whoever plays the first elf dies very quickly, at least in my playgroup that's how it works. But to finish up this long winded comment, me likey elves and thanks for the input.

0
Posted 10 July 2013 at 14:27 in reply to #376097 on nath

Permalink

the card you are looking for is hivestone.

0
Posted 10 July 2013 at 14:09 in reply to #374767 on MIMEOSLIVERS! edh

Permalink

Craig only has only one deck now ... mono white, I'm sure you can think of the general he would use. I have played it and lost to it (more than once) and I told him that I will not play with him again until he breaks that deck. It's not unbeatable, I will not list here all the ways it could be stopped but it is somewhat annoying to start the game over again every turn for 3 turns in a row and for him not to suffer any losses and for him to still be in a position to win. Oh and before I forget I have posted a new deck so give it a look see.

0
Posted 09 July 2013 at 19:34 as a comment on Dimir EDH

Permalink

I have never made a jund dragon deck so I don't really have lots of ideas about what to say or what should be added or subtracted. About 3 weeks ago someone in my playgroup had a karrthus edh deck and it was working out well for him but my memory is not so good and I could not say exactly what he had in it. Look at a card called conspiracy, I like it a lot and have used it in more than one deck. It would help you to potentially get more use out of dragonspeak shaman and crucible of fire. That's all I got right now, if I come across something else that would be helpful I will let you know.

0
Posted 09 July 2013 at 18:42 as a comment on Jund Judgement edh

Permalink

I also found nether traitor, oversold cemetery, demonlord of ashmouth, skirsdag high priest.

0
Posted 09 July 2013 at 17:22 in reply to #375151 on shirei

Permalink

I will be glad to give you some criticism about whichever deck you decide to post if you want me to. Leave another comment here when you are finished and I will get to it when I can.

0
Posted 09 July 2013 at 17:14 in reply to #375617 on doran

Permalink

Frankenstein's monster is not a beast he would be a monster no a zombie, I know what you meant and he would be amazing, similar to a sutured ghoul. I have the knell and I that would be a way to recover after mass creature kill. Belbe's armor is darn good but another card I don't have. I think I would just interested in increasing the defense of my creatures for this particular build. I agree the crenellated wall is a great card along with the umbra. I have been looking for some other cards to add, think I want to keep the theme as treefolk if I can. Again many thanks Jester.

0
Posted 09 July 2013 at 17:10 in reply to #375613 on doran

Permalink

161-180 of 378 items