pigeons

man i really like this deck. it's like a better, faster version of what i was trying to do with this one haha http://www.mtgvault.com/pigeons/decks/unblockable-battlemaster/

gonna hijack your deck to talk to you again(why is there no inbox feature? haha)....check out this deck i made, i really like it. http://www.mtgvault.com/pigeons/decks/trickery-and-nonsense/

wanted to know what you thought of it, and it'd be awesome if you could answer all the rules questions i posted on it too haha...was just trying to make a combo heavy, interesting budget deck.

edit: oh and you'll notice every card is from avacyn restored. i bought 12 booster packs from that set recently and i liked how all the cards paired, so i was trying to use exclusively cards from that set.

hah! i have that card

i don't understand why werebear is in here when you have so many cards that draw from your graveyard...it just wastes the threshold doesn't it? or am i missing something?

alright so i'm shelving this idea for awhile: the new challenge, help me make an all blue deck composed of nothing but sea creatures? fish, jellyfish, crabs, eels, krakens, leviathans, squid, whales and whatever else. no merfolk or beasts. got any ideas for how to make a deck like this work, or what cards to include?

try howling mine or font of mythos if you need more cards? could easily drop a hydra or two to fit some in


could also slap in some aqueous form. scry + it makes your hydras unblockable for just one blue. also gives you more cards to use that blue mana on.

hahaha that's insane...basically a turn 2 or 3 win if you get the combo out in your opening hand and have a red sun's zenith

oh hey you made a deck today too haha...wanna help me with mine? http://www.mtgvault.com/pigeons/decks/ramp-and-burn/ i can't decide if it's awesome or crap and over kill haha


i like your deck by the way. i always wanted to make an eldarzi deck but wasn't sure how to make it work

is it possible to be competitive in vintage with cheaper decks, or do they all basically have to be like this one? haha

almost 7k? i'm out...

ah gotcha, i thought i was just missing an obvious combo or something haha

isn't bojuka bog counter-productive to what the deck does? don't you want as many cards in their graveyard as possible? otherwise it's awesome. love nemesis of reason, had never seen that card before.

decks that have no mana to cast their spells are WAY too powerful. just, no.

OP and unfair, trash it.

well here's what happened, we played a 3-person tournament thing where the first player to 3 wins won. prize was a pool of 4 theros booster packs, and each loser got one pack. it ended up being me and him at 2-2 a piece, and we were locked into a deadlock. he had over 500 life and a serra avatar that was 500/500 or something nuts...and he ended up winning but here's the thing that i didn't realize until 3 days later...we had both got so drunk we completely forgot about commander damage. i swung him about 8 turns straight with prossh, and most of those turns he was boosted to 8/5 or higher. so i should have won with commander damage hahaha....so knowing that, yeah the deck seems far less scary now. we just forgot about it.

oh well, can still play it against friends :P

check the cards. the dragon deck i made is only illegal in everything because of the sol rings. might be okay if you just replace that card with a similar one. not sure though.

this is the only eternal bargin deck list on the site, so i'm going to use your deck to leave this comment. me, my best friend and his wife all just bought commander decks. the best friend bought eternal bargin, i got power hungry and she bought nature of the beast. eternal bargin is by FAR the most over powered and broken of the three. the power level seems to be 1.) eternal bargin, 2.) power hungry, 3.) nature of the beast....for an idea of how insane it gets, i was locked into a stalemate with him last night where he had a serra avatar on the board that was like 500/500+ and he had over 1,200 life. good luck countering that. i could have stalemated almost endlessly thanks to the tokens, but i finally conceded. there was no hope, nothing i could do to break it. here's some revisions i made to power hungry specifically to counter his deck: http://www.mtgvault.com/pigeons/decks/prossh-power-hungry-edh-2/ bottom line is, if you don't bring lots of artifact, enchantment and creature removal against eternal bargin, you're going to lose. you have to break up combos involving these cards asap: serra avatar(period. doesn't even need to combo with anything really), cradle of vitality, ajani's pridemate(this thing just gets nuts so fast, it was up to 16/16 before i could drop it and that was without any combos going yet), pristine talisman, sanguine bond, well of lost dreams, wall of reverence(this paired with serra is just broken) and divinity of pride. these are the cards that will kill you once they start combining with each other. nevinyrral's disk is a big threat too, but only in the early game or out of desperation. you won't want to cast it once your combos are out, cause it'll board wipe them too. oloro is so broken and good you barely even need to deploy him, just leave him in the command zone and gain endless life. back to power hungry: you almost HAVE to switch to shattergang brothers as your commander. i stubbornly stuck with prossh throughout the whole mini-tournament and probably lost because of it. shattergang can break his combos pretty effectively. hopefully some of this advice/observations will help others having trouble beating eternal bargin :P

hah! hilarious combo

i don't know about the land curve, but how about 4 surging flame?