Mcholypotato

Yeah...I don't think you know how sacrifice and regenerate mechanics work.

How did this deck make it to the front page when it doesn't even work!?

I wouldn't run just 1 of's of some of the lands. You only have one win condition and if just a single land is destroyed you're completely fucked. I have a similar deck to this but guildgates aren't the only win condition. Even in this deck you could run 2 of every guildgate and not get fucked on mana, so I would drop two selesnya guildgates and up the others.

http://www.mtgvault.com/mcholypotato/decks/spectrum-of-defeat/

I like the idea of this deck a lot, nice job.

I like it, reminds me of my bird deck but they play slightly differently.

http://www.mtgvault.com/mcholypotato/decks/to-kill-a-mockingbird/

Blowfly is a field wiper, I'd personally take out Corrosive Mentor. You don't need all your creatures to have wither.

Here's my wither deck that just rocks face to give you an idea of where I'm coming from. http://www.mtgvault.com/mcholypotato/decks/wither-in-bloom/

I'd also add dark ritual, getting 6 swamps is rather hard with no draw mechanics, land fetch, or mana ramp. 11 of your cards cost 5+ mana

Scar or Virulent Wound would be a nice addition

What is this? You only fulfilled half the Scott Standards for deck quality requirements; you have the Vampire Nighthawks but no Dungeon Geists. I don't even know you anymore.

Or better yet, just go to deck search and type, [Zombie Infestation] [Treasure Hunt]

This deck and variations of it has been posted so many times on MTGVault

I think you have far too many merfolk to make this a viable deck even in casual.

I'm aware of that, but using braid of fire for one card is a waste of a card slot

Braid of Fire is a nice card but you can only use instants or abilities with it because mana pools drain between phases, so all those sorceries with X in them don't benefit from Braid of Fire at all.

You should put your commander in the sideboard, makes it a lot easier to tell who the commander is. I mean right now it's obvious since you have like 18 cards, but when you get to 100 it will be too much to search for a commander without being annoyed.

I would add Scrapyard Salvo

Oh and Dark Ritual might be a good idea for solid black so you can get some of the fatties out sooner or drop Dusk Urchins, Necro, or blowfly on turn 1.

Looks alright; I'd drop some cards and put in Scar or Virulent Wound, those cards are pretty mean.

Have a look at my wither for some ideas.
http://www.mtgvault.com/mcholypotato/decks/wither-in-bloom/

eater of days

no I understand, we play very different magic formats so I suppose it's just not what I'm used to. Your decks are largely standard and I don't even know what's good in standard anymore.

-_- Those are some of the decks that I'm talking about.