Xyqueum

If you're going to play it as legacy then why not use Arcane Denial and Counterspell. I would dump all those counter-X spells and replace them. Seems liek 1 more Academy Ruins might be a good idea. The rest of this deck sounds gawdawfully nasty. I wanna play it so liek yu need to make it......k bye.

Ahh ok. So what do you think of my deck?

This is Roger not Noah. Noah can be contacted on Startingflavor

HAHAHAHAHAHAHA!!!!!!! which one of you 3 made this deck?

Check out my Wildebeest deck. I put a card called Loaming Shaman in the sideboard. I think he would be an awesome mainboard piece. What do you kidlets think?

Time Spent constructing MONO BLUE EDH deck precisely as the rules dictate........3 hours.

Money spent to buy the cards.........Under $500.00

Slapping down young smart ass upstart........PRICELESS!!!

Lets examine gross stupidity. EDH decks contain 100 cards including the COMMANDER. Now analysis of the main deck shows 100 cards but wait for it......the intended COMMANDER is in the sideboard and not in the 100 card MAIN DECK. Conclusion...if the COMMANDER were to be added then this deck would contain 101 cards in the MAIN DECK. Funny thing about this is that a certain someone unwisely chose to try and make fun of my correctly constructed MONO BLUE EDH deck by pointing out that it had the wrong card count. Naturally I felt obligated to point out to this person the error of their ways. Moral of this story is make sure you have your own shit together before talking shit to a grand master such as myself. Have a nice day :).

Actually smart ass, The main deck is 100 CARDS. I put the commander (also listed in the PRECISELY 100 CARD MAIN DECK) as a sideboard so I can remember who the hell it is. QED SFB.

Ur Jelis cuz I madeded da koolish decker and its liek perty and all bloo u no. so liek look at da new EDH perty bloo decker. NO FAPPING!!!!

I was thinking more about cards that would allow you to put that dude into play; more Demonic tutor-like spells. How about that spell that enchants a land so you can tap it to draw cards. Its a black card. I cannot remember the name of it. That would be helpful too.

Drop the medallions. Love the counter doubler. Would love to build a deck around 4 of them. Sisters of Stone Death too costly and no synergy. Remove Stalker Hag. Remove Garruk Relentless. Add more cards to get that counter doubler into play. That creature drives the deck so you want him every game thus you need to make sure you can always dive for it. Try to find more ways to get it into play. Overall I like the deck. May be slow but once its moving it should be lethal.

Initial thoughts are as follows: I like the artifacts so they can stay. I have only spot checked the rest of the decks but I see some weaknesses. You have about 3 lands too many and are lacking about 8-9 creatures. Like I told M you want a 3:1 ratio on creatures or you are going to get outcrittered and pounded. Make some adjustments and let me know when you are finished. Feel free to keep things as they are but you will need to argue your point.

My first instinct tells me you got suckered into "o this looks cool" syndrome and this has led to your deck being unbalanced. If you want to keep things as they are then be prepared to defend and argue against this point. Good Luck.

consider adding Mikaeus, the Unhallowed to your deck. Seems like it would work well with your theme.

4 Tournament wins, 1 top 4 and 2 top 8 for a total of 7 out of 7 top 8 or better. Smallest tournament to date was 12 people which I won. Largest tourney was 42.

consider these spells: path to exile, sin collector, spear of heliod, renounce the guilds, avenging arrow, blood baron of vizkopa (really nice game breaker even if not one of your 3 types).

You lack board sweeps. I would remove the 3 or 4 land destructions ( too few to be effective) and replace them with some nice board sweeps like nevinral disk and the great spell damnation ( awesome art). now you have a way to set things proper if you get off to a slow start.

If I were you I would dump all those useless artifacts and replace them with more critters. You have plenty of land since you are at that 1:3 ratio you can expect to see 2 lands in your opening hand. So, more mana is nice but unnecessary. Another way to look at it is this; if the game was on the line do you want to draw one of the artifacts? no, you would want an instant or creature. Give that some thought as you sweep through your deck again.

FYI: I run with 34 and 32 creatures in my 2 EDH decks. In my opinion you are running a bit light. recheck all those instants and sorceries you have in this deck and ask yourself do you really need this instant or did you get sucked into the "this looks cool" syndrome. Remember that your deck needs to be efficient and by that I mean that it needs to be able to deal with all threats equally if possible. With only 26 critters + commander you can expect to see 1 creature per 4 cards drawn. you would like to be around 1.5 per 4 or even better 1 per 3. That's why I run with 1/3 of my deck with creatures so that I can be at that nice yummy 1:3 ratio. Hope this helps.

something else to remember is that if a commander has died several times and therefore has several death counters on it and then gets sent to the library it would cast for normal and all death counters would be eliminated. Only if it goes to command center would it gain and keep death counters. Well done on your research.

won a 10 man modern tournament today with the red deck. It was awesome. I tell you more tomorrow at D&D.