UncleZoid

Very original idea! +1 from me

may I ask why no plummet? Seems like a nice direct removal, although whirlwind is definately better.

Lose hope is kinda nice for the scry, but I admit there's so much better stuff, even just disfigure.

Indulgent Tormentor is very nice, but it loses against Desecration imo.
I was thinking about Dash Hopes, maybe for sideboard material.
Painful quandary is kinda slow i think.

Thank you for the comment and the tips!

In my experience the Gray worked very well as a finisher some times and if not it definately made a nice gap!

You're right about Nevinyrral's Disk, I just created the deck with what I had in my collection at this time, but I'm probably going to buy a couple of those.
Same goes for the Underworld Connections/Phyrexian arena situation, although being able to choose wheter to draw or not is useful sometimes.

I'll raise the verdict to 4x, and maybe some more Sorrows, but why the hate against the Victim of the Night? To me it seems like a pretty good direct removal compared to Doom Blade or even Smother.

Thanks for the comment and the tips!

2 despise and 2 duress seems like a great idea, I'll test that
thoughtseize is a no, because it's kind of a budget deck