I've been thinking a lot about it. Immortal servitude is clearly a more powerful card, but Return to the Ranks is more versatile. Both are potential win-cons, and if I have the mana/creatures Return might actually be better. Yet if I have those resources late-game it kind of makes Return a 'win-more' card.
Permalink
Both work in their own way, immortal might be better overall but it all depends on the situation. I bought 4x Return so I'll be playing it regardless haha. Also what would you recommend? I've been thinking about making some changes, possibly throwing in Order of the Stars > Mortician Beetle and Silence > Brave the Elements.
Immortal servitude IS pretty good actually. If I get my hands on some I'll playtest them. My only complaint is that it means I can't call back my Blood Artists and Dark Confidants with the same spell I can get back my Kami, but I can see how massively powerful immortal servitude could be in a deck like this.
Hey I made a deck very similar to this recently, mind giving me some constructive advice? http://www.mtgvault.com/slimslamer/decks/the-middle-path-wb-pacifist/Have you considered Mortician Beetle? Its not a human, but it complements your Champion of the Parish's nicely. When a creature comes into play CotP gets a boost, and then when it leaves Mortician gets a boost.
41-44 of 44 items