McRay

You really should get some Unwinding Clock in here Period :P

But nice deck

Windbrisk heights allows me to get high mana cost cards sooner than expected (raise the alarm you get 2 soldiers then attack with another 1). For the setup time, I have a couple of low cost that allow me to sustain early aggro but as I said this deck is slow but powerful.

But for your deck, you should consider the Forbidding Watchtower, if you have extra mana, getting a 1/5 on demand is great.

*meant solid in the end, not soldier :P

I must say I love Soldiers deck, yours is simply lacking one thing, high mana cost,

Most of the soldiers are weak and you need cards such as Captain Of the Watch or Conqueror's pledge,

maybe have less allies and focus on the soldiers aspect since the allies only get really good in allies only decks.

You need also some utilities cards such as Brave the Elements, with it you can easily go in an all out attack most of the time.

One last thing, if you could check out my own soldier deck I'd appreciate (Its more based on tokens but its really soldier, only a tad slow).

http://www.mtgvault.com/ViewDeck.aspx?DeckID=238922

Thanks for the tip 'bout chalice, I'll check this out.

Check out my own deck, its similar to yours, but you NEED to add golem foundry to your deck

http://www.mtgvault.com/ViewDeck.aspx?DeckID=162902

I really do like your concept with Mindcrank, good work :P.

Nice Idea, however I would have some recomendation

-Replace unsummon by Vapor snag, its the same thing but the opponent lose 1 life
-MindCulling cost WAY to much of mana to be efficient get some Visions of beyond (U: draw 1 but if a library has <20 cards you draw 3)
-Piracy charm is cool but there is another charm that could be used as a milling spell Vision Charm
-You are NEVER gonna cast Jin-Gitaxias before you die or the opponent does.
-2 traumatize are enough for a mill deck, (% of draw and effect wise)
-Since you are playing legacy, get some REAL counterspell in there or at least a counterspell with a twist.
-The shelldock isle is good but not with 4 in a deck, as you are potentially putting some good cards in the bottom of your library.
-If you really want to optimise your hedron Crab, get some fetch land (Terramorphic or the *lose 1 life* stuff) as you get the double landfall.
-Last but not least, you need more mill spell than tomescour, archive trap isnt reliable enough and traumatize only worth casting once.

PS : Check out my mill deck, it works great.
http://www.mtgvault.com/ViewDeck.aspx?DeckID=210342

The meaning of this is simply to fetch one using Enduring ideal, and even that it is simply to make your solitary confinement last forever, but you can still use Form of the dragon right away to kill your opponent if you know they have nothing to disturb you

Honestly this is more of a control deck than a mill deck simply beceause :
1-You don't have enough creatures to kill some1
2-Your only mill card is a planewalker that cost 5 mana to play

also, 4 day of judgement is way too much, cut 2.
Your mana curve is also very high and I think you lack mana acceleration (chalice wont supply it)
If you want a Mill deck, at least throw 2 traumatize in it, or else you'll have a hard time Milling some1.

If you want ideas for some good mill cards, here is a link to my mill deck, its a multiplayer casual but its good.

http://www.mtgvault.com/ViewDeck.aspx?DeckID=210342

That would be cool if you could comment it as well.

Maybe try Frontier Guide to force the landfall, it's only basics land however, you judge

I'd remplace phantom warriors with metharan soldier (2 CMC 1/1 unblockable) and add some Ornithopters (0 CMC 0/2 flying) great with ninjas.

I Realy love your deck, helped me improve my own.

If you could give me advices on mine I would apreciate

http://www.mtgvault.com/ViewDeck.aspx?DeckID=120113

Thank you

Nice concept but personnaly I would have 4 tome scour in a mill deck (1 mana, mill 5) plus it fits well with your ''cast a spell do stuff'' idea

Go check my own Mill deck and comment if you wish
http://www.mtgvault.com/ViewDeck.aspx?DeckID=114760

you should not have 4 traumatize, it's useless to have so many remove live 2 of them and add forced fruition or something like that

Go check my own mill deck and comment if you wish
http://www.mtgvault.com/ViewDeck.aspx?DeckID=114760

try traumatize 1/2 the opponent's deck is out for 5 mana, pretty neat

just so you know ponder is restricted to 1 per deck

you should get enlightened tutor to get your 2 win condition

http://www.magiccards.info/arena/en/22.html

If you have the budget add Glimps the unthinkable 15 dolars each UB : mill 10 cards

http://www.magiccards.info/rav/en/208.html

I'll suggest you get :

4-Field Marshal
2-3-Raise the Alarm
1-Mobilization
4-DARU WARCHIEF!

you should also take out :
palace guard
rox pikemaster
your smiths
your elite vanguard

here is my version of a soldier deck coment it please

http://www.mtgvault.com/ViewDeck.aspx?DeckID=70194