MattCherrie

Dude, I build physical decks. Some of my lists are old builds, so I currently have 21 EDH and 4 modern decks. Personally, I think that is quite a lot of decks to have and I've put my blood, sweat and tears (and quite a lot of money) into putting them together. As for comments, I post when I have a constructive comment or when I'm genuinely impressed by a deck - like this one. As SpliNter said, quality over quantity.

How many of those 453 decks have you actually physically built? How many have you played? I suspect you are more of a theorist than a player, and that's fine, but please stop trying to tell people how to curate their own shit. We're all different.

By the way, the reason a lot of EDH decks dont have descriptions/guides is because they don't need them. In most cases, the commander does a thing and the deck supports it in doing that thing. What more is there to say?

Anointed Procession would also be amazing.

Land Tax is awesome in any deck that has white in, but it's a pricy boi!
I'd definitely think about Helm of the Host though, it could get pretty silly after a few turns.

The pathway lands have allowed me to remove most of the proxies from my decks. So long as I can get the colour I want when I want it, I'm happy.

Why don't you make a new deck and whinge in the description like usual? Maybe another shitty lantern mill modern deck?

Wilteddankman
"Hibernation from 2013 to 2017, a shift to posting only EDH upon awakening" Yeah, almost as if I moved away and didn't have playgroup for a few years... Such suspicious behavior.

I post EDH because I play EDH, and I own every deck I've posted here. I use this site to keep track of my decks because I prefer the interface to the likes of TappedOut, etc. I'm gracious enough to make my decklists public, so that others can use them for ideas. I couldn't give a fuck about your lists.

As I've said to you before, I think these "trolls" are probably just trying to piss you off personally, probably took offence to you telling people off for not writing descriptions how you want them to. That's probably why your rep is -1000, too. I'd downvote you if I could, but I dont have enough rep.

I like it! It seems nicely focused around the commander, with only the minimum of mono-colour spells. The mana curve is pretty low and it's budget friendly! Could Ferrous be the new Feather?
As you've got a lot of instant and sorceries, have you thought about including [[Firesong and Sunspeaker]]? Could be funny with [[Blasphemous Act]]. :)
(bonus upvotes for telling Wilteddankman where to shove it)

How about Thassa, Deep Dwelling? An extra bounce each turn might come in handy!
Freed From The Real and Pemmin's Aura will both allow you to untap Roon as long as you have mana.
Agent Of Treachery is a great flicker target which would allow you to draw more too.

How about Stromgald Cabal? It's a knight, it's under $1 and it lets you counter white boardwipes!

I literally threw this together from my folders as I didn't want to spend anything on what I see as a troll deck, but that's a great idea! I might throw in Ankh of Mishra, Back to Basics and Winter Orb if I can find them.

Thanks!

Drop the big mana green enchantments, I've found that they tend to draw a lot of attention and make you a target. Go for lower cmc cards that synergise with the rest of the deck and make people have to do maths before they realise how big they are - All That Glitters, Ancestral Mask, etc. Thay can also be fetched back with Sun Titan.
.
Drop the ramp spells and go for enchantments that make your lands better - Fertile Ground, Gift Of Paradise, Dawn's Reflection. This way you'll get more enchantress triggers too!

Might want to get rid of the Mountains and have more Forests and Plains!

You're not wrong. I've got Ashnod's Altar and Altar of Dementia in another deck where they don't do much, so I'll chuck them in too. AoD adds another wincon as well! Really trying not to spend any actual money on this one.

Spawning Pit right now, Ashnod's/Phyrexian Altar if I had them. I'll add a couple more because I think it probably needs more than one. (Fallen Angel and Defiant Salvager going in)

Hydradoodle inserted as a placeholder until Neverwinter Hydra gets added to the database - it's very nearly the same damn card!

You could go more into the deathtouch side - Fynn the Fangbearer makes it into a win con. Ohran frostfang and bow of nylea help with this.
If you're determined on staying all-elves, try Strixhaven Stadium. Suddenly, every 1/1 they let through brings them 10% closer to death.

It's a good that my playgroup are fine with proxies. There's no way I could afford revised duals in every deck,. I do have a few of them, but they don't leave their toploaders for fear of damage.

True, but I like to keep the sb for cards I want to add to the deck.

You're not wrong! If I get another copy it'll probably go in. Not a fan of the old one though, it's too much of a hate magnet.

That's Prophet of Kruphix, and it is unfortunately banned in commander.

I don't think it does. Did you mean something else?