CiaranMadgrin

396 Decks, 283 Comments, 87 Reputation

Malignus imo isn't too spectacular. Sure, on the attack he's great when Xenogos is out, but when Xenogos isn't, he's just very meh. And Ruric Thar's awesome, but I already had a bunch of awesome creatures and needed more smaller stuff to help the deck's curve.

0
Posted 12 September 2020 at 11:30 in reply to #635987 on EDH: Unstoppable Force

Permalink

Those are both great ideas, I just dunno what I'd take out. I'd prefer to stay as zombie as possible for those sweet synergies, but a big eldrazi would be a good idea to keep the deck from deck. The mill isn't too big, but it could be worrying against like Phenax or Nekusar.

1
Posted 11 September 2020 at 06:21 in reply to #635826 on EDH: Bow to the Necro-Queen

Permalink

Umm....terminate is red, so technically it's black splashed red. I mean, it's even got ancient grudge man. At that rate just sprinkle in some of the tarkir life lands and call it a day. Also, why even play gargantuan? It's big and unearth for 2B is nice but it doesn't really add to the 8 Gary plan. Stuff like Evil Prescene does though.

0
Posted 23 July 2019 at 03:44 as a comment on Pauper Big Black

Permalink

Hey Putrid Leech can be pretty good. It's beaten me plenty of times in Pauper for underestimating it.

0
Posted 01 July 2019 at 14:06 in reply to #625905 on Pauper: Landslide

Permalink

Kor Skyfisher mostly. Also some decent sideboard stuff and Journey. Plus simic imo is better at stuff like emerge or tron.

0
Posted 01 July 2019 at 12:16 in reply to #625905 on Pauper: Landslide

Permalink

I agree, but I think when Pauper Masters comes and shifts the meta it'll have a better chance. It's weird enough to catch people off guard.

0
Posted 01 July 2019 at 06:32 in reply to #625878 on Pauper: Landslide

Permalink

Yes....but Goblin Gathering is cool. And the more you play, the better you get :3 Honestly, this is the most competitive build for Goblins imo. It's ok, and I really made it just to play Goblin Gathering. I'm already working on an actually competitive Goblin list, and even in that one Hordeling Outburst may not make the cut.

0
Posted 30 June 2019 at 04:52 in reply to #625874 on Pauper: Mogg Gathering

Permalink

I thought about the counterspells, but find in Commander the ones in the deck are stupidly good. Arcane Denial feeds card advantage and can be very political, Dissallow turns off a lot of problems, and Dissipate's exile is a great way to take something really bad out you don't want potentially coming back. I personally like Sakura-Tribe Elder's chump capabilities, but definitely am reconsidering Wayfarer's Bauble. It's pretty good in this deck, how did I not see that xD.

1
Posted 29 June 2019 at 07:01 in reply to #625858 on EDH:Muldrotha's Value Cemetery

Permalink

I just wanted some extra removal at instant speed. I looked into Deathsprout, but need the permanent removal over just creature removal. The deck has plenty of value, but is a bit lacking in the control department.

1
Posted 29 June 2019 at 06:57 in reply to #625859 on EDH:Muldrotha's Value Cemetery

Permalink

I think if we changed the Oathbreaker to Domri, then we might as well change the entire deck. Domri is a radically different Planeswalker, and honestly this deck is supposed to be casual and fun. I mean, I thought the deck description gave it away that I'm not taking my werewolf deck too seriously when they are already a very flawed tribe. I love Innistrad werewolves, and since I've actually tried them in Modern I can easily say from experience it's a rather tricky deck to pilot anyway. I personally don't think Oathbreaker will take off and am just building fun decks while it's relevant, and if it does actually get somewhere as a format I'll take a swing at a more serious deck. I would personally rather use Xenagos for GR, but that's just my preference.

1
Posted 13 June 2019 at 21:04 in reply to #625471 on Oathbreaker: Moon Shines Red

Permalink

Nothing like a mana curve of 1-2 in your mono creature deck. You thought burn was fast? Like me show you my SLIVER SPEEEEEEED.

0
Posted 12 June 2019 at 10:07 as a comment on Nayan Slivers

Permalink

It's got a mana curve of zero! Obviously too good for Standard, or even Legacy! Since everything has no mana cost it's FREE. AMAZING GRACE....HALF THE MANA, TWICE THE PRICE...........

1
Posted 12 June 2019 at 10:05 as a comment on Unbeatable Combo

Permalink

Thanks! The Zubera version I made was surprisingly good, and know that the deck has an update an a more competitive edge in mind, it's pretty fun. It's not the best deck but it's my favorite deck in pauper beside Dredgehold.

0
Posted 09 June 2019 at 02:16 in reply to #625368 on Pauper: Beetles & Bones

Permalink

Living death was originally in the list, but after dropping down to 26 creatures I figured I could find other wipes. I almost went Kirtar's wrath, but I like cheaper-on-mana wipes. Never heard of Twilight's Call however, I'll look into it. Thanks for the feedback!

0
Posted 30 September 2017 at 07:33 in reply to #606942 on EDH: Death Sentence

Permalink

thank you very much! If only I had that kind of passion for decks that aren't commander xD

0
Posted 30 September 2017 at 07:31 in reply to #606934 on EDH: Death Sentence

Permalink

Zubera was my favorite tribe in Kamigawa. I hope they come back :3

0
Posted 05 July 2017 at 23:24 in reply to #602551 on Spiritual Disturbance

Permalink

Seriously? When I read what it does I wanted to buy like 8. It seems really good at first

0
Posted 17 June 2017 at 23:58 in reply to #601865 on Dragon Skred

Permalink

If you're in modern, why not run some more cheap dragons? Get more value for Draconic Roar?

0
Posted 17 June 2017 at 06:53 as a comment on Dragon Skred

Permalink

I saw a bit of it, then decided I just didn't have the patience for it. I saw some comments but don't want to read the novel's worth of comments of either A) "deck revisions," B) ego stroking, C) valid criticisms that are repeated multiple times, D) "self defense" in the form of temper tantrums and obvious hot air, or E) valid frustrations of very well informed Vaulters. While I for one know what it's like to make a fun deck and praise it to high heaven just to be proven it's not as crazy as I thought it is, I'm always up to listen to people who know more than I do. At heart, I'm a fun & casual kind of player. and I know that if guys like you or NorthernWarlord or DedWads comments, don't be stupid and listen to what they have to say. There is a difference between hard-headed and just plain egomaniacal, which it appears this deck builder is. I'd go on about what else I see, but this message is long enough. I'm not wasting any more time with this deck, I'm just here to reply to your comment at this rate.

To the builder, in the words of Kendrick Lamar (and I hate that guy): Sit down, be humble.

2
Posted 17 June 2017 at 06:41 in reply to #601850 on BEST Tyrn 1.5 Kill Land Dek??

Permalink

Why not have both instant speed land destruction spells? Hit them after they fetch to make them lose a life for nothing?

0
Posted 17 June 2017 at 02:13 in reply to #586764 on BEST Tyrn 1.5 Kill Land Dek??

Permalink

21-40 of 283 items